Rummell-Brill Insurance
127 West Main Street
Plain City OH 43064
614-873-8221

Insurance Claim Information

Claims Philosophy

You are a valued client and deserve to be treated as such. By dealing with your local agency, you are dealing with someone you know.

We are here to assist you during the claim process and help ease your mind. We are here to answer your claim questions. We can suggest competent repair or contractor facilities. We do have a Quick Claim process when it is within draft authority.

Please call our office during regular business hours to report a claim or you may file your claim directly with your insurance company. A list of claim office telephone numbers are listed below.

  • Auto Owners Insurance Company 1-888-252-4626
  • Auto Owners Flood Insurance 1-800-356-6663
  • Auto Owners Road Trouble Assistance 1-888-869-2642
  • Foremost 1-800-435-7764
  • Hagerty Insurance 1-800-747-5348
  • Hagerty Boat Insurance 1-800-762-2628
  • Hastings Mutual Insurance Company 1-800-442-8277
  • Hasting Mutual Glass Claim Call Center 1-800-255-7137
  • MAX 1-877-971-6300
  • Met Property and Casualty 1-800-854-6011
  • MetLife Glass 1-800-343-8434
  • Ohio Fair Plan 1-866-255-5530
  • Progressive 1-800-274-4499
  • Progressive Commercial Auto 1-800-274-4499
  • Progressive Roadside Assistance 1-888-776-2778
  • Safeco 1-800-332-3226
  • State Auto Insurance Company 1-800-766-1853
  • State Auto Glass Claims 1-888-504-4527
  • West Bend

If the claim is an Emergency, please call 614-873-8221 during regular business hours.

During Non-business hours please call, Jenny Brill 614-519-9175.