About Us

What can we do for you?

Rummell-Brill is an independent insurance agency based in Plain City. We represent a select list of insurance companies including some large regional and national companies you have seen on television. We have access to a wide selection of coverages so that we can find what is best for you.


Free Insurance Quote

It doesn't cost a cent to explore your options. Let us help you identify your needs. Do you own a home, vehicles or other valuables that you would want replaced if lost, destroyed or damaged? How will you pay for health care? Do you have a source of income to support your family if you should become ill or injured and unable to work? How would you recover if you suffered loss or damage to your crops, farm, or other income producing business?


Our free quote provides the basis for a plan, a comprehensive insurance strategy customized for your personal or business goals. Insurance is protection, so that you can feel secure today as you build your dreams for the future.


Business Philosophy

We are always glad to see you! Whether you are purchasing insurance or filing a claim or just have something you want to talk about, the door at Rummell-Brill Insurance Agency is open to you. We help take the mystery out of insurance with honest answers that are easy to understand.


We do the work for you.

We do the research, find the answers to your questions and help you make sense of it all. You don't have to "shop around" because we do it for you.


We build relationships.

We stand behind our promises to you. We care about you and your family. We work to build long lasting relationships so that we can continue to meet all of your changing insurance needs throughout the years.

Customer Service, A Family Tradition

The agency founder, Joe Rummell, first opened the door to his friends and neighbors in 1948. His mother, Daisy Sharpe worked with Joe until she retired at the age of 82. Joe’s wife, Wanda Rummell worked in the agency from 1967 until 2015. Joe formed a partnership with his daughter Jenny Rummell-Brill in 1977. In 1982 Joe’s son-in-law Brian Brill joined the partnership: and now with more than 40 years of experience Jenny Rummell-Brill and her daughter Roselynn Cassady, carry on the family tradition of honest reliable service.

Everyone at Rummell-Brill is dedicated to customer service and satisfaction.


You are not just another number to us - You are No. 1!

We care about our insureds. We know that after a claim you need to know that we are taking care of you and that the job is getting done right to get you back to where you were prior to your loss. We follow up after we've taken care of your claim to hear your thoughts. We want to know if you liked what we did for you, or if you have suggestions on how we could have better helped you.

Request a Quote

Thanks! Message sent.