Rummell-Brill Insurance Agency, LLC

127 West Main Street
Plain City, OH 43064
Phone: 614-873-8221

Fax: 614-873-8871

Email Us 

© 2019 Rummell-Brill Insurance | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

Carriers

Ever wonder which way to turn? Let Rummell-Brill do the work for you. We have researched the market and have chosen a select group of companies offering a wide range of insurance coverage. Talk to us about your needs and we can help select the company and coverage that fits your needs best.

Claims Philosophy

You are a valued client and deserve to be treated as such. By dealing with your local agency, you are dealing with someone you know. We are here to assist you during the claim process and help ease your mind. We are here to answer your claim questions. We can suggest competent repair or contractor facilities. We do have a Quick Claim process when it is within draft authority. Please call our office during regular business hours to report a claim or you may file your claim directly with your insurance company. A list of claim office telephone numbers are listed below. If the claim is an emergency, please call 614-873-8221 during regular business hours. During non-business hours please call, Jenny Brill at 614-519-9175.

Pay Bill Online

Thank you for the opportunity to serve you. Rummell-Brill Insurance Agency takes pride in serving you in all your insurance needs. We understand that due to busy schedules, not everyone can stop by the office to pay his or her bill.

Please click on the link to the proper company, and then follow the directions provided by the company.

Auto-Owners Logo

Auto-Owners Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

517.323.1200

888.252.4626

American Reliable Logo

American Reliable

Phone:

800.535.1333

American Strategic Logo

American Strategic Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

866.274.8765

866.274.5677

FIGO Pet Insurance Logo

FIGO Pet Insurance

Phone:

844.738.3446

Foremost Insurance Logo

Foremost Insurance Group

Phone:

Claims:

888.888.0080

800.527.3905

Hagerty Insurance Logo

Hagerty Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

877.922.9701

800.922.4050

Hastings Mutual

Hastings Mutual

Phone:

800.442.8277

Medical Mutual Logo

Medical Mutual

Phone:

800.382.5729

MetLife Logo

MetLife

Phone:

Claims:

800.854.6011

800.638.5000

Ohio FAIR Plan Logo

Ohio FAIR Plan

Phone:

800.282.1772

Progressive Insurance Logo

Progressive Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

800.776.4737

800.274.4499

Safeco Insurance Logo

Safeco Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

800.332.3226

800.332.3226

State Auto Logo

State Auto

Phone:

Claims:

614.464.5000

800.766.1853

UnitedHealthcare Logo

UnitedHealthcare

Phone:

866.633.2446

VFIS Logo

VFIS

Phone:

Claims:

800.233.1957

800.233.1957

VacantExpress Logo

VacantExpress

Phone:

Claims:

800.310.3351

800.788.4780