Welcome to Rummell-Brill Insurance

The Rummell-Brill Insurance Agency is known in the Plain City area as people you can trust for professional service, a welcoming smile and an honest handshake that means we will be there for you and your family in time of need.

Our Motto

Do the right thing. Do the best we can do. Treat others the way we want to be treated.  -- Lou Holtz


We Listen to You

Our professional staff analyzes your specific insurance requirements, then searches the market for the best coverage at the best price based on your own individual needs.


We represent a select list of insurance companies including some large regional and national companies you have seen on television. We have access to a wide selection of coverages so that we can find what is best for you.


  • Auto Insurance

  • Classic and Antique Vehicle Coverage

  • Home Insurance

  • Farm Insurance

  • Boat Insurance

  • Motorcycle Insurance

  • Recreational Vehicle Insurance

  • Commercial Insurance

  • Workers' Compensation

  • Life Insurance

  • Disability Insurance

  • Health Insurance

  • Specialty Coverages

  • Notary Services

Request a Quote
Visit Us



Rummell-Brill Insurance Agency, LLC

127 West Main Street
Plain City, OH 43064
Phone: 614-873-8221

Fax: 614-873-8871

Email Us 

Rummell-Brill Insurance | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy